Feminenza logo
link to Feminenza website
Feminenza Home page
Magazine Home page
Winter Issue 2006
link to articles from this issue

Summer Issue 2006
link to articles from this issue

Spring Issue 2006
link to articles from this issue
Winter Issue 2005/6
link to articles from this issue
Summer Issue 2005
link to articles from this issue
Spring Issue 2005
link to articles from this issue
Issue 3,2004
link to articles from this issue
Issue 2,2004
link to articles from this issue
Issue 1,2004
link to articles from this issue
  Issue 4, 2003
link to articles from this issue
 Issue 3, 2003
link to articles from this issue

Issue 2, 2003
link to articles from this issue

Issue 1, 2002

link to articles from this issue

 

B O O K R E V I E W
of Pope Joan
By Donna Woolfolk Cross

Book image: Pope Joan by Donna Woolfolk CrossPope Joan (who has ever heard of a female Pope!) is one of the most fascinating and extraordinary people in Western history– and one of the least well known. Not many people have heard of Joan the Pope, and those who have, mostly regard her story as a legend.

Yet for hundreds of years – up to the middle of the seventeenth century – Joan's papacy was universally known and accepted as true. In the seventeenth century, however, the Catholic Church, under increasing attack from rising Protestantism, began a concerted effort to destroy what they regarded as embarrassing historical records of Joan's papacy. The Vatican seized hundreds of manuscripts and books and Joan's virtual disappearance from modern consciousness attests to the effectiveness of these measures.

One ancient copy of the Liber pontificalis (overview of all Popes since St. Peter) still exists and contains a record of Joan's papacy. The entry on Joan is obviously a later interpolation, clumsily pieced into the main body of the text. Blondel, a Protestant historian who examined the text in 1647, concluded that the entry on Joan was written in the fourteenth century.

The book Pope Joan was written making use of the facts of Joan's life as far as they are known, and has been accurately placed in historical context. The author chose to make it a work of fiction, as the truth of what really happened between 853 and 855 AD, the supposed years when Joan was Pope, can never be fully verified.

The story paints a vivid picture of the early 9th century and transports you there. This is the time where the empire of Charlemagne is at its peak and extends into the greater part of Europe. Louis, son of Charlemagne, was crowned Emperor in the year 813. A large part of the story of Joan takes place during the reign of Louis. Joan grew up in the area of what we now call Germany. During this period, women hardly had any rights and Joan, who clearly is a very bright girl, with the help of her older brother Mathew, secretly manages to learn to read and write. Later, a Greek scholar, Aesculapius, who is contracted to teach her younger brother John, spots her rare intelligence and devotion to learning and manages to convince her father to allow her to further develop her reading and writing skills and to learn Latin and Greek, alongside her brother.

Aesculapius manages to get her a place at the schola at Dorstadt, to further her education. Her father forbids her to go and sends his son, John. Joan manages to escape with her brother and so she continues her education, with much resistance from her fellow male students. The evening she arrives she has a debate with, as it later turns out, Odo, the master of the schola. She out reasons him in public, and he never forgives her for this and later this will be a determining factor in her fate. She develops a special friendship with Gerold, the man who takes her into his home.

Her life gets brutally changed by a Viking raid on the village Dorstadt, when the whole congregation is gathered in the church. She manages to hide from them and turns out to be the sole survivor of the entire village. At that moment Gerold is far away, serving as a judge in courts of justice in service to the Emperor. Joan manages to flee to a monastery, where she enters under the guise of her younger brother and is called John Angelicus from this day forward. In this Monastery she receives her religious education and becomes the apprentice of the community's physician. She has access to all the material about medicine and healing in the extensive monastery library and in the end surpasses her master.

She then decides to go to Rome, where she is asked to heal the reigning Pope Sergius. She succeeds and becomes his friend and looks after him for the rest of his life. Leo succeeds Sergius and he installs Joan as his Commander- in-Chief of the papal militia. For Joan this is a soul-searching moment, as Gerold whom she has met again in Rome and she has come to love, asks her to marry him, to leave Rome behind and to raise a family. All her life she has trained herself for duty, which is now calling, and she decides to stay and work with the idealistic Pope Leo. He then dies unexpectedly, and to her amazement, she is voted to be the next Pope.

Following many intrigues she meets her end only two years later, during an uprising of a rival contender to the Papacy. Due to the shock of seeing Gerold being killed, she gives birth to their stillborn child and bleeds to death on the Via Sacra, which was called the 'shunned street' after this incident. It was only then that people found out that they had had a female Pope in their midst! After the shocking occurrence with Joan, papal processions deliberately began to turn aside from the Via Sacra, 'in abhorrence of that event.' The street was not used again until in the 16th century.

Joan had a strong impact on all those around her, as she was seen to be a humane and truly devoted Pope, full of compassion for all people, irrespective of their station in life.

Throughout the centuries it has not been easy for women to escape the shackles that society put upon them and so there were many women who made their dream come true by portraying themselves as men. For example in the third century, Eugenia, daughter of the Prefect of Alexandria, entered a monastery disguised as a man and eventually rose to the office of Abbot. Her disguise went undetected until she was forced to reveal her sex as a last resort to refute the accusation of having deflowered a virgin. In the twelfth century, St. Hildegund, using the name Joseph, became a brother of Schönau Abbey and lived undiscovered among the brethren until her death many years later.

The light of hope kindled by such women flickered in a great darkness, but it never entirely went out. Opportunities were taken by women strong enough to have a vision. Pope Joan is the story of one of those visionaries.

So far this book only appeared in English, published by the Ballantine Publishing Group, Copyright © 1996 by Donna Woolfolk Cross. ISBN: 0-345-41626-0. First edition: Nov. 1997.

Buy this book through Amazon.co.uk or Amazon.com

Return to article index for issue 2, 2004 of Feminenza Magazine


In Association with Amazon.com

Top

Feminenza stands for the encouragement of every woman's future

Search Now:
In Association with Amazon.co.uk